The story begins on 26th March, 1971 when
West Pakistan began its military crackdown on East Pakistan’s struggle for
independence. You know some of what happened next – India, under Indira Gandhi
intervened to support the Bangladeshi cause, which sparked the India-Pakistan
war of 1971, which India won in spectacular fashion. The Pakistani Army
surrendered and Bangladesh became an independent country – a massive political
victory for India, a greater personal victory for the Prime Minister.
But our story happens in the sidelines, away from the
public eye which is always distracted by the limelight. West Pakistan’s
military attack on erstwhile East Pakistan created panic, many were displaced
from their homes. Refugees flowed into India and the eastern states of West
Bengal and Assam had to accommodate them. At the time it was obviously
unbecoming of the Government of India, the liberator of East Pakistan, to turn
the helpless refugees away. We did accommodate them... at the time...
Refugees are always a tricky subject. When swathes of
foreigners flood any neighbourhood, it creates certain concerns and
apprehensions. For starters, where do they live, how long will they stay, who
provides for them... and refugees obviously overstay their welcome, where else
will they go? Can you trust these people, who speak a different language, eat
different and even behave differently? Any instance of crime is readily blamed
on the flux of these foreigners and if the neighbourhood is not doing too well
for itself, they are an unwanted economic strain no taxpayer is willing to
bear, not to mention an invasion of the local culture.
Towards the end of the decade Assam wanted these
refugees out of the country. “Which refugees?” the Government responded. Ten
years is quite a long time and by then, with people settling into their new
homes and finding jobs to keep things moving, the differences between local and
foreign had blurred out. This led to a series of protests and in 1985 the
Government of India signed the Assam accord, promising that the illegal
immigrants who had entered the country after 25th March, 1971 would
be identified and deported.
Enter NRC – National Register of Citizens, a document
which attempts to identify the refugees... sorry, I mean illegal immigrants and
deport them. Last year the Supreme Court gave our Government an ultimatum and
this year finally the process was completed. Nearly 19 Lakh people were unable
to prove that they had entered the country on or before 25th March,
1971 and hence will not be treated as citizens. It is hard to imagine what
these 19 Lakh will do now, how will they leave the place they thought was home
for the past 48 years? That is a humanitarian question and begs much wider
discussion. We will come back to that.
Ofcourse, how the NRC identified a person as citizen
or not is an entirely different question. There were reports of a soldier who
had served our country during the Kargil war being left out of the list.
Further, how the destitute people of our own country will prove their
citizenship is another question; in our country where even the Prime Minister
struggled to show his degree certificate. These thoughts will deeply trouble
any person who has been following the news. But over the last week, our
Government has given the most perverted twist to the story by introducing the
Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 2019 and getting it passed by both the houses of
our Parliament.
The Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 2019 (or CAB)
provides that persons belonging to Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh, Christian or
Zoroastrian community, non-Muslims basically, who entered India before 2014
from Pakistan, Afghanistan or Bangladesh fearing religious persecution will be
given citizenship in India.
Let me first pay respect to the apparent merit of this
legislature. Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh are Muslim countries and are
known to have persecuted the religious minorities in their respective
countries, so our nation’s intention to welcome them seems... But let’s look at
it a little deeper.
First of all, why have we opened our arms only to
these religions and not all religions? There are certain sects among the
Muslims, such as the Ahmediyas in Pakistan and Shias in Afghanistan who have
faced religious persecution. Secondly, why are we sympathetic only to these
three countries? What about the Rohingyan Muslims who were attacked by the
majority Buddhists in Myanmar, or the Srilankan Tamils who faced the rife of
civil war in their motherland for generations? And till now, I have only spoken
about the refugee crisis in our neighbourhood. As a global power, that we claim
to be, our country must not turn a blind eye to the civil war in Syria and the
strife in Sudan either. Shouldn’t India, as a citizen of the world, take an
active part in saving the innocent from genocide, wherever it happens, to
whomsoever it happens?
And most importantly, why just religious persecution?
What about the people who fled their country following a natural disaster. The
Sunderban forests are frequented by floods and cyclones displacing the local
community, Hindus and Muslims alike, in both sides of the Bengali border. What
about the economically depressed who flee their country from an unbearable load
of debt? India could take a leaf from UK in learning to accommodate such
people. Oh wait, only the absconding billionaires are welcome?
All these questions only point towards the absurdity
of this act. The larger issue of constitutionality and much larger issue of
humanity need no discussion. The CAB is an irrational, inhuman, abhorrent piece
of cattle faeces, an abundance of which right now threatens to strike at the
founding principles of our country.
To understand the real implications of the CAB it must
be read along with the NRC. We noted that 19 Lakh people were left out of the
NRC. Now, the Government wishes to legitimise a section of those “illegal
immigrants” through the CAB. Now, the non-Muslims can stay back as citizens of
India, only the Muslims have to leave.
The CAB is a statement of intent. Our eastern borders
are quite porous and anyone who is able to grease the RIGHT hands can find his
way inside our country. Or inside any country! So what purpose does the CAB
serve? A) It gets rid of the genuinely helpless and destitute while silently
accommodating the corrupt and fraud. B) Read with the Home Minister’s statement
that NRC will be implemented throughout the country, the intent is clear as
day!
Now what happens to these “illegal immigrants” where
will they go? Will Bangladesh accept them as their citizens? Does our nation
have resources to deport so many people? No, they won’t be deported. They will
continue to stay in our country, as citizens without citizenship. They will
work at our construction sites and our fields, without Adhaar, without ration,
without a BPL card, without voting rights, without education, healthcare or
even a death certificate when the time comes. The vision of certain pre-independence
ideologues is much closer to reality now.
India is hailed as the most tolerant country in
history. We have given home to every person who has come in search for one. We
are the only country in the world with a thriving Parsee community. We are the
only country in world has not been hostile to the Jewish community. Budhism,
Jainism and Sikhism were born out of the womb of our Motherland; Christianity
and Islam have also found home here. Our country has the third largest Muslim
population in the world after Indonesia and Pakistan. It was this tolerant
spirit that the makers of our constitution sought to protect in framing India.
It is that spirit of tolerance and equality that, to this day, differentiates
India and Pakistan. It wasn’t religion that split us, it was tolerance. While
Pakistan is home for Muslims, India is home to everyone! Today, our soul is
threatened by this Bill.
So what do we do about this? Today morning I tried to
explain this subject to one of my students. After I spoke, he asked me in a
raging voice, “So what do we do about this?” Well, that’s a good start. At
least ask the question! So what do we do about this?
Love
Shaeyyy...
ReplyDeleteThanks man...
DeleteNice write up Ramon! Keep going! There could be more aspects to dwell upon this matter. But as you rightly said, it's a good start and let's ask questions and enlighten ourselves more about this and form an opinion thereafter. Cheers! :)
ReplyDeleteThank u... Yeah, every debate puts light on a different aspect of this issue... Do comment ur views too...
DeleteNice write up Ramon! Keep going! There could be more aspects to dwell upon this matter. But as you rightly said, it's a good start and let's ask questions and enlighten ourselves more about this and form an opinion thereafter. Cheers! :)
ReplyDeletegreat writing brother!
ReplyDeleteThank you Brother...
DeleteGood writing.keep it continuing.
ReplyDeleteThanks Ji
DeleteWell Articulated in simple way
ReplyDeleteThanksQ bro...
DeleteIndia's GDP rank in the world is 5th. Per capital rank is 126. As a country we are immensely rich; as an individual, each one of us is poor. Yes, even the richest of the rich in our country is rich only inside his house. Out on the street, reality in the form of poverty will strike him on his face. From the comforts of the house to glass house office, He has to pass thru the dirt, filth and garbages. That's where He must realise his rank is 126 !!!
ReplyDeleteEconomically we, as individuals, are still far behind. We CAN'T afford to take into this country, anyone on the basis of their economic condition. Poorer country in the neighborhood cannot burden India by sending their people here.
Yes, we are humane. Probably we rank number ONE in terms of humanity. We have always been.
So if someone is oppressed, when a particular sect is facing extinction in the neighborhood, we MUST open our door for them, so that they shall survive.
CAB is one such humane Dharma. It is made law in this country so as to enable the implementation.
Forget for a moment our affiliations & prejudices and think purely on the basis of economy of this country, CAB will be understood better.
Great writing sir...
ReplyDeleteThanks!
DeleteMr Ramon, you write well and people who read your blog get influenced by your style of writing. Young students look up to you as you are so educated cost( and charted accountant.)
ReplyDeletePrecisely why you should avoid writing misleading blogs!!!
CAA is a simple law PERTAINING to those minorities getting persecuted in the three of our neighbouring country and hence approaching India as refugees!!! For other refugees of any sort, we have other laws, we also abide by United Nations rules and regulations and most importantly, we have never in the history have refused entry of refugees into our country any time.
So PL DO NOT confuse people by mixing secularism and CAA. It is absurdity of the first order.
Sir you are a well educated man in influential position as a TEACHER.
Please! It's a request! You don't confuse people by inducing falsified facts.
If your paradigm itself is distorted, please read diverse write ups on CAA, understand and form new perspective. And if you are prejudices by "keralian thoughts of communism" , you must STOP writing for the sake of the country.
Natives in this country are in peril under the budgions of so called mighty minorities and meek minnows in the neighborhood.
Sir you changing your paradigm will benefit thousands of young students.
Hi... Thanks for your comment... But this article is written after proper research and wide discussion across a spectrum of opinions... There may be some lapses in my discourse, but the I strongly stand by the basic premise of my argument. The CAA is draconian in design and inspires a deep sense of concern for all Indians
Delete